If you enjoy fishing and want to find new ways to appreciate this sport, you must have come across the canoe vs kayak fishing debate.
Both types of boats are slim and long and need to be powered by the paddler in them. Fishing on canoes and kayaks is slightly different as each paddling boat has its specific advantages and disadvantages. Before going further, it’s helpful to understand the most visible difference between the two boats.
Fishing kayaks usually require paddlers to sit on top keeping their legs either bent or extended in front, only facing forward. This is why it’s harder to twist around in kayaks. Meanwhile, canoes require paddlers to sit a bit higher, while also allowing them to look around with more ease, even letting them get up if they wish.
Here’s a quick guide to help you determine which boat is better suited to your needs when you go fishing!
We may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you when you buy through links on our website.
Learn more about our Amazon affiliate program
Canoe vs Kayak for Fishing: Pros and Cons
People often weigh these two options on their hunt for a memorable fishing experience. Before embarking on a comprehensive comparison between the two types of fishing, it’s relevant to consider the different reasons people give while opting for a kind of fishing.
Common Reasons Why People Opt for Canoe and Kayak Fishing
There are a variety of reasons why some decide to go fishing in a canoe or a kayak that has the best kayak outriggers, which can help prioritize your requirements, helping you decide which one is better for you.
Here’s a quick list of the most common ones:
- For an unorthodox fishing experience
- Are small boats that are easy to get in and out of
- Are usually commandeered by one person, allowing more control over the fishing trip
- Closer to the water so able to see interesting underwater structures that make excellent fishing spots
- Allows anglers to access and cover larger water areas
- Preferable to those who like to fish while sitting down
- Potential to catch more fish
These are just a few of the reasons that people give while going fishing in a canoe or kayak.
Four Points to Consider Before Deciding Between Canoe vs Kayak Fishing
When deciding, it’s relevant to weigh in the strengths and weaknesses of each of the boats.
Here’s a list of some points to consider that would help you determine which type of fishing you would prefer, aiding you in making a more informed comparison.
While considering canoe vs kayak fishing one of the most crucial things to factor in is the total stability of the boat type.
Canoes have a higher seat than kayaks, which raises the center of gravity of an angler, making them less stable. For those people who prefer to reel out a big catch such as pike while standing up, this factor is a notable disadvantage, unless you develop the skill with frequent practice.
On the other hand, kayaks seat people closer to the water thus lowering the center of gravity, allowing them to have more overall stability than canoes. Kayaks are mostly ‘sit on top’ boats that have larger width on their beam, allowing more stability even for people standing upon them.
Managing Rougher Waters
This depends on the ability of the boats to navigate rougher water and weather conditions. As mentioned before, canoes are less stable as they have a higher center of gravity due to their higher seat.
Such a combination obviously doesn’t mesh well with rougher waters, causing canoes to rock in choppy waters, and even tip over in bad weather conditions, especially if managed by a beginner.
Kayaks are known to be able to handle rougher water conditions due to their wide beam. Some kayaks are ‘sit on top’, and despite the fact that they are still more stable than ‘sit on top’ canoes, they are best used in calm waters.
Fishing is a sport requiring patience as well as a considerable investment of time. It’s obvious that you will only be able to devote more time if you are comfortable. It’s important that you consider which choice grants you the most comfort and overall ease.
As canoes usually have a ‘sit on top’ feature, it ensures that people are higher above the water, making them less likely to get wet while casting your line for fishing.
Kayaks are larger and offer greater legroom along with various footholds to facilitate greater levels of comfort. It should be known, however, that the sitting place on a kayak is built into its hull, which people usually think is less comfortable for longer spans of time.
One of the most important things that you should consider is its hauling capacity.
While going fishing you need to take all the necessary equipment such as fishing rods, lines, reels, and enough bait and tackle to last the trip. You also need space to store the fish that you’ve caught.
Kayaks sit lower on the water, which makes the things on them more likely to get wet. Storage space on a kayak varies across different makes and models; however, kayaks typically don’t have much storage space as they are flat.
Canoes tend to have more storage space available; however, the stored objects are not likely to escape getting wet, especially when used by beginners.
Choosing between canoe vs kayak fishing depends primarily on your personal preferences and skillset. Some people intend to go on longer fishing trips and require their water transportation to provide comfort, while beginners tend to gravitate towards the type of fishing that offers better stability.
As you can see your choice depends squarely upon what you expect from a successful fishing trip. It helps to evaluate the pros and cons of choosing a particular type of fishing beforehand in order to have smooth sailing.
Despite their differences, both canoe and kayak fishing are exciting sports to indulge in.